Do you tend to toss and turn when you sleep? Do you often fall asleep on your back, only to wake up at a weird angle?
You might be what is referred to as a combination sleeper.
A combination sleeper is someone who constantly shifts sleeping positions — from the back sleepers and stomach sleepers to the side sleepers, often in the same night.
This is exceptionally common and usually not something to worry about.
Unless it’s time to buy a new mattress.
There are so many types of mattresses these days — some are firmer, others softer, some are thinner, and others thicker. So how do we choose between the options?
We’ve compiled a list of the best mattresses for combination sleeping in 2024 that you can buy online. But first, here are some tips to look out for when picking a mattress.
The Problem of Plenty: What to Look Out For in a Mattress
Firmness
Depending on body type and sleeping positions, firmness levels plays a significant role in ensuring you get a good night’s sleep. Some mattresses are firmer or softer, while others feature a mix of both. Medium-firm mattresses are generally recommended for a combo sleeper, as either too much firmness or softness can cause pain.
Support
Some mattresses feel like a hug; others feel like you’re lying on the floor. The ideal mattress should land in the middle — supporting the body, maintaining spinal alignment regardless of sleeping position, distributing weight, and supporting pressure points.
Motion Transfer
If you share a mattress with a partner who constantly groans about how much you move and thrash about all night, you should look for a mattress with motion transfer. These mattresses isolate movement and prevent it from disrupting the other person’s sleep.
Breathability
Some people get very warm when they sleep. If this is the case with you, look for mattresses that offer good airflow and heat dissipation. Latex mattresses and materials like memory foam layers work best. A hybrid bed mattress, which features a combination of both springs and foam layers, prevents overheating and offers the support that combination sleeping needs.
Durability
Mattresses are expensive. So when making a new purchase, consider investing in a mattress made of high-quality materials that will stand the test of time. There are also ways to extend the durability of a mattress, such as rotating them at regular intervals.
Personal Preference
The right mattress is one that feels comfortable to you. Don’t be afraid to try out several options to find what works best.
This brings us to our ultimate mattress review.
The Best Mattresses For Combination Sleepers
| Brand | Best For | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Editor’s Choice |
|
Overall | Shop Now |
| 2 |
|
Hot Sleepers | Shop Now |
| 3 |
|
Luxury | Shop Now |
| 4 |
|
Pressure Relief | Shop Now |
| 5 |
|
Couples | Shop Now |
| 6 |
|
Organic | Shop Now |
| 7 |
|
Back Pain | Shop Now |
| 8 |
|
Extra Firm | Shop Now |
| 9 |
|
Plus Size | Shop Now |
| 10 |
|
Budget | Shop Now |
| 1 |
|---|
|
Editor’s Choice
Best For:
Overall
|
| 2 |
|
Best For:
Hot Sleepers
|
| 3 |
|
Best For:
Luxury
|
| 4 |
|
Best For:
Pressure Relief
|
| 5 |
|
Best For:
Couples
|
| 6 |
|
Best For:
Organic
|
| 7 |
|
Best For:
Back Pain
|
| 8 |
|
Best For:
Extra Firm
|
| 9 |
|
Best For:
Plus Size
|
| 10 |
|
Best For:
Budget
|
Best Overall: Helix Dusk Luxe
- Mattress type: Hybrid mattress
- Price range: $1,373.80 – $2,373 (20% discount available)
- Firmness scale: 5-6/10
- Trial period: 100-night sleep trial
- Warranty: 10-15 year warranty
What I Loved!
One of the best mattress brands of 2024 for combination sleepers, the Helix Dusk Luxe is not too firm, soft, and ideal for couples with different sleep preferences.
It features a zoned lumbar support for enhanced contouring and three foam layers for support on pressure points. It also offers spinal alignment, back pressure-relieving, and structural stability with perimeter edge support, making it a delight to lay on after a hard day.
What I Didn’t Love!
- Reviews report that it tends to sag after a few years.
- The warranty and trial period aren’t as long as its competitors.
Best For Hot Sleepers: Aurora Luxe
- Mattress type: Hybrid mattress
- Price range: $1,199 – $2,665 (25% discount available)
- Firmness scale: Comes with several firmness options.
- Soft mattress: 3/10
- Medium mattress: 5/10
- Firm mattress: 7/10
- Trial period: 120-night sleep trial
- Warranty: 10-year warranty
What I Loved!
Brooklyn Bedding’s Aurora Luxe has been designed to prevent overheating while you sleep. It is possibly the most cooling mattress on the market today, ideal for hot sleepers. The fibers used in the mattress remove excess heat from the surface, while a layer of cooling-infused foam absorbs excess body heat.
Meanwhile, this hybrid mattress contours according to your position and comes in three variants — soft, medium, and firm. The medium option, I’ve found, is probably the most ideal for combination sleepers.
What I Didn’t Love!
- It is on the pricier side, especially considering it only has a 10-year warranty
- It isn’t ideal for people who prefer extra firm beds
Most Luxurious: Leesa Legend
- Mattress type: Hybrid mattress
- Price range: $1,999 – $2,999 (further discounts available)
- Firmness scale: Medium plush feel — 3/10
- Trial period: 100-night trial
- Warranty: 10-year limited warranty
What I Loved!
The Leesa Legend is one of the only luxury mattresses on this list to feature a dual-coil system — offering comfort and support in equal measure.
It’s made of organic and eco-friendly materials, but it is still exceptionally durable and has a premium feel. Anyone looking for extra pressure relief for their hips and shoulders should consider this hybrid mattress. It’s also perfect for combination sleepers who dislike the feeling of a memory foam mattress.
As a plus, Leesa even adds 2 free extra pillows with every purchase.
What I Didn’t Love!
- It’s definitely pricier than other mattresses on this list
- It isn’t worth it for lighter people who don’t need extra support.
Best In Pressure Relief: Nolah Signature 12”
- Mattress type: All-foam mattress
- Price range: $1,299 – $2,049 (with 20% discount available)
- Firmness scale: Medium plush feel — 4-5/10
- Trial period: 120-night trial
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
What I Loved!
The Nolah Signature was designed with one goal in mind — to focus on all pressure points in your spine, hips, shoulders, and other joints. This foam bed has billions of microscopic air bubbles that evenly distribute body weight, offer full body support, and help deal with aches and pains.
The foam the company uses is said to be 300% more durable than a memory foam mattress. The fact that it comes with a lifetime warranty shows the company’s confidence in this claim. Apart from helping deal with shoulder, hips, and spine pain, its medium-soft feel is ideal for combination sleepers.
What I Didn’t Love!
- It doesn’t offer as much support on the edges
- It may not be ideal for those looking for a firmer mattress
Best for Couples: Bear Star Hybrid
- Mattress type: Hybrid mattress
- Price range: $1,298 – $2,796 (with 35% discount available)
- Firmness scale: Medium-firm mattress — 6.8/10
- Trial period: 120-night trial
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
What I Loved!
This hybrid mattress isn’t just designed for combination sleepers; it’s also made for couples who change positions all night. It has a responsive mattress which has a comfort foam that adapts to all body types and sleep positions while offering pressure relief. An additional high-density foam provides noticeable support and durability to the entire mattress. It’s ideal for combination sleepers, and is also great value for money, as it comes with a lifetime warranty!
What I Didn’t Love!
- Its motion transfer quality makes no difference to people who sleep alone and might not be worth the investment if that’s the case
- It may not be ideal sleep surface for those who sleep strictly on their stomachs, as they tend to sink into the mattress
Most Eco-Friendly: Birch Natural
- Mattress type: Hybrid latex mattress
- Price range: $1,373.80 – $2,411.30 (with 20% discount available)
- Firmness scale: Medium firm — 6-7/10
- Trial period: 100-night trial
- Warranty: 25-year warranty
What I Loved!
If, along with a mattress made for combination sleeping, you’re looking for an eco-friendly option, the Birch Natural is the way to go. Its latex foam is made up of hypoallergenic and organic materials that offer pressure relief and contouring that your body sorely needs while at the same time keeping you cool at night.
Plus, it’s certified to be free of any toxic emissions. While its commitment to using only organic materials is a huge plus point, it’s also ideal for combination sleepers as it offers an extra bouncy feel.
What I Didn’t Love!
- The extra bounce might not be so good for couples who sleep together and tend to change positions through the night
- Those on the heavier side may prefer some extra firm feel
Best for Back Pain: Helix Twilight
- Mattress type: Hybrid mattress
- Price range: $936.30 – $1,748.90 (20% discount available)
- Firmness scale: 8-9/10
- Trial period: 100-night sleep trial
- Warranty: 15-year warranty
What I Loved!
The Helix Twilight, much like the Helix Dusk Luxe, is one of the best hybrid mattresses for combination sleeping on the market today, with one added benefit — it’s great for dealing with lower back pain too. Its medium to firm firmness and foam layers act as cushioning on the most common pressure points, including shoulders, hips, and back.
It’s firm and supportive without feeling too hard on the back and offers great motion isolation, making it a good choice for couples.
What I Didn’t Love!
- It isn’t the best option for those who enjoy softer mattresses
- It may not work too well for very light people who might find it too firm
Most Firm: Plank Firm Luxe
- Mattress type: Hybrid mattress
- Price range: $924 – $1,732 (25% discount available)
- Firmness scale: 7-9/10
- Trial period: 120-night sleep trial
- Warranty: 10-year warranty
What I Loved!
Designed for extra firmness, Brooklyn Bedding’s Plank Firm Luxe offers some of the best support and is ideal for those who prefer a hard mattress instead of one that lets you sink into it. This hybrid mattress comprises very thin comfort layers placed over supportive coils, giving you all the extra support you need. It’s also very effective at dealing with shoulder or lumbar pain.
It’s a favorite for heavy people, as it doesn’t sink too easily. As a plus, both sides of the mattress can be used — the top layer is firm, while the bottom is ultra-firm, allowing you to customize as per preference.
What I Didn’t Love!
- It doesn’t work for those who prefer a softer feel
- It’s too firm for those who are lighter
Best for Heavy People: Titan Plus Luxe
- Mattress type: Mixed foam hybrid mattress
- Price Range: $899 – $1,799 (25% discount available)
- Firmness scale: 5-7/10
- Trial period: 120-night sleep trial
- Warranty: 10-year warranty
What I Loved!
Designed to offer extra support to heavy people, the Titan Plus Luxe is a medium-firm mattress ideal for stomach sleeping, back sleeping, and side sleeping. The Titan Plus is made up of layers of quality foam, along with extremely strong coils. It is modestly priced compared to other mattresses in its league and offers extra support for heavier people. It isn’t too firm, either.
What I Didn’t Love!
- It doesn’t offer the versatility that some of the other mattresses do
- It only comes with a 10-year warranty
Best Budget Mattress: Dreamfoam Essential
- Mattress type: Memory foam mattress
- Price range: $599 – $1,149 (25% discount available) (All prices are for the 14” variants. Dreamfoam Essential is also available in 6”, 8”, 10”, and 12” options, which range from $205.50 for a twin version to $524.50 for the king size.)
- Firmness scale: Between the 6” and the 14” inch variants, the Dreamfoam Essential offers different firmness.
- 6”: 7-9/10
- 8”: 6-8/10
- 10”: 5-7/10
- 12”: 4-6/10
- 14”: 3-5/10
- Trial period: 120-night sleep trial
- Warranty: 10-year warranty
What I Loved!
If some of these mattresses seem appealing to you but also a bit pricey, you might want to consider the Dreamfoam Essential. This is one of the best memory foam mattresses and it comes in so many shapes and sizes that there’s guaranteed to be one for every preference and type of sleeper.
I don’t need to list them all, but what you should know is that they’re all extremely affordable, without compromising features- including contouring, cooling, and pressure point relief. The quality of this mattress and the number of features it offers at this price is unbeatable.
What I Didn’t Love!
- It wasn’t as cooling as some of the other mattresses on this list
- It didn’t offer much in terms of motion isolation, so it may not work so well for couples with different sleeping positions
Conclusion
When we set out looking for the best mattress for combination sleepers, we went looking for several factors — firmness, durability, motion transfer, and support. What we came back with was this list of our top picks. To figure out which is best for you, don’t hesitate to try out a few options — hopefully, the features listed on here should help you make your decision.
For more mattress reviews, check out Home of Cozy’s picks for the Best Mattresses of 2024, or the Best Floor Mattresses of 2024.